From Research to Reasoned Argument
How can writers use research from multiple sources to develop a fair, convincing argument about a complex issue?
Free for educators. The PDF includes the staged student tasks, alignment to New York standards and the Portrait of a Graduate, and success criteria.

The big idea behind this assessment
Effective research-based arguments synthesize relevant information from multiple sources to support precise claims with sound reasoning, while addressing counterclaims and crediting sources. Writers strengthen their arguments through revision and apply the conventions of formal, academic writing.
How Portrait of a Graduate skills are embedded
Each skill is tied to specific student work in this assessment. Here is what students do and what that work shows.
What students do, stage by stage
The performance-based assessment moves through clear stages. Each stage ends in a student task with the standard or skill it shows.
New York standards assessed
Mini Masteries: lesson-level performance tasks
Short Portrait of a Graduate tasks built into the unit's lessons, so students practice the skills before the final assessment. Each one is in the lesson PDF.
Download the assessment and unit materials
Unit Performance-Based Assessment
From Research to Reasoned Argument
The full assessment: essential question, staged student tasks, alignment notes and success criteria.
Download the PBALessons with Mini Masteries
Every lesson, each with its Mini Mastery task, plus the weekly planners.
Open the folderBuild performance-based assessments for your district
Curriculum Genie helps your team create unit PBAs and lesson-level Mini Masteries aligned to your standards and your Portrait of a Graduate.
